2016 taught Hollywood a tough lesson about sequels: You should only make them if your audiences are demanding them and you should give them exactly what they want. Some of the years’ biggest blockbuster flops include The Huntsman: Winter’s War, Ghostbusters, and Zoolander 2. Sadly, there is a Disney release to add to this list, Alice Through the Looking Glass.
Released six years after Tim Burton’s Alice in Wonderland, the sequel makes a number of big mistakes. The biggest, losing the acclaimed director who has a unique and diehard fan base. The second is Time, both as in the distance between the two films and also as a weak main character. And the third is a thin plot that relies on your love of Johnny Depp as the Mad Hatter in order to feel emotionally invested. These are serious crimes for a film with a budget close to $200 million.
Having returned from her sea voyage, Alice finds hew power threatened by a man she scorned years ago. Returning to Underland by way of a mirror, she discovers that the Mad Hatter has lost his “Muchness.” Now she must break the rules of Time, an actual person who controls the ticking of the clock, to travel back in time to fix the Hatter.
The first film made $330 million domestically and $1 billion worldwide. This helps put into perspective how big of a flop Looking Glass was, which earned $77 million domestic and $299 million worldwide. And while most sequels are almost guaranteed to make less than the original, 70-80% less is a larger than average decline. There was very little buzz around Through the Looking Glass when it was announced and even less when the trailers debuted.
As evidence that Disney had bigger expectations for Alice Through the Looking Glass, the film arrives on Blu-Ray with more bonus features than the first film received. Now available as a Blu-Ray/DVD/Digital HD combo pack or standalone DVD, you can bring home this sequel. Thankfully, it’s one of the studios’ few duds from recent years. (Note: There is no 3D release in the US, but fans can import it from the UK).
Video
Alice Through the Looking Glass is presented in its original 1:85:1 aspect ration in 1080p. Wonderland’s vibrant color palette is expertly rendered in HD and the Blu-Ray offers a stunning presentation with a tremendous amount of detail.
The DVD loses a lot of detail and clarity in comparison to the Blu-Ray and also offers a more pastel looking color palette.
Audio
The default audio track on Blu-Ray is a 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix. It’s an engaging mix that puts you at the center of the action and gives the subwoofer a lot of work to do. Other options include a 2.0 Descriptive track, plus French and Spanish in 5.1.
All four audio options are available on DVD, except for the 7.1 mix which has been replaced with a 5.1 condensed version.
Bonus Features
- Behind the Looking Glass (8:39) – Director James Bobin, producer Tim burton, screenwriter Linda Woolverton, Helena Bonham Carter, Anne Hathaway, Sacha Baron Cohen, and Johnny Depp deconstruct the story with on-camera interviews and behind-the-scenes clips.
- A Stitch in Time: Costuming Wonderland (4:24) – Costume designer Colleen Atwood talks about updating the costumes for the sequel and all of the hidden details you won’t see in the film.
- Characters of Underland (4:47) – James Bobin and Linda Woolverton discuss each of the characters. This feature is dedicated to Alan Rickman.
- Time On… (1:46) – Sacha Baron Cohen improvises as Time, discussing the time he met Lewis Carroll and how he played multiple characters in the film.
- Alice Goes Through the Looking Glass: A Scene Peeler (2:27) – James Bobin introduces a comparison of the blue screen shoot vs. final effects of the scene where Alice steps through the mirror.
- Alice Goes Through Time’s Castle: A Scene Peeler (1:33) – Another comparison of the moment where Alice has to jump across the hands of the clock to reach Time’s castle.
- Music Video: “Just Like Fire” by P!NK (3:58) – Pop singer P!NK performs her hit song in a video inspired by the film where she steps through the mirror and plays a host of Underlandian characters.
- Behind the Music Video (3:02) – P!NK discusses working with Disney and the concept for the video.
- Audio Commentary (1:52:57) –James Bobin leads this single audio commentary of the film. Without anyone to talk to, the track has some moments of dead air and is mostly very boring.
- Deleted Scenes ( 8:56) – Five deleted scenes are offered with optional audio commentary by James Bobin.
- Alice’s Bedroom and Rabbit Hole
- Alice Tackles Hamish
- Time Comforts Racie in the Sitting Room
- Racie in the Castle
- Time Can’t Follow Alice
The only bonus feature on the DVD is “A Stitch in Time: Costuming Wonderland.”
Packaging & Design
The standard Blu-Ray case houses both discs on either side of the interior. Inserts include a flier for Disney Movie Club and a single generic sheet that features your Digital Copy/Disney Movie Rewards code. The case is housed inside of an embossed slipcover that swaps the white mirror found beneath with an actual reflective surface around the title.
Both discs open with ads for Disney Movies Anywhere, Beauty and the Beast 2017, and Finding Dory. Selecting “Sneak Peeks” from the main menu plays additional ads for Disney Movie Rewards, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, Shadowhunters, and Once Upon a Time.
Final Thoughts
It is my opinion that Alice Through the Looking Glass is not worth owning. However, fans of the film will find stunning picture and audio quality and some worthwhile extras on this Blu-Ray release. For everyone else, I recommend remembering the 2010 film for what it was and not tarnishing it with this poor follow up.